fdsrun

FDS cell size: D*/δx and the mesh sensitivity study

fdsrun editorial team · · 6 min read

How to choose the FDS cell size: characteristic fire diameter D*, the D*/δx index, cubic cells and a grid convergence check.

"What cell size should I use?" is the most common question from new FDS users. The NIST documentation answers honestly: it depends on what you are trying to achieve. The recommended route is to start with a relatively coarse mesh and refine it until the results stop changing appreciably — a mesh sensitivity study (FDS User Guide, section 6.3.6). Below are the tools that make it a sensible exercise.

Characteristic fire diameter D*

For buoyant plumes, resolution is measured by the non-dimensional ratio D*/δx, where δx is the nominal cell size and D* is the characteristic fire diameter:

D* = ( Q / (ρ∞ · cp · T∞ · √g) )^(2/5)

Q is the heat release rate, ρ∞ ≈ 1.2 kg/m³, cp ≈ 1.0 kJ/(kg·K), T∞ ≈ 293 K, g = 9.81 m/s². D*/δx can be read as the number of cells spanning the characteristic diameter of the fire — the more, the better resolved the fire dynamics. If the heat release rate changes over time, so does the resolution.

Heat release rate QD*δx for D*/δx = 4δx for D*/δx = 10δx for D*/δx = 16
100 kW0.38 m9.5 cm3.8 cm2.4 cm
500 kW0.73 m18 cm7.3 cm4.5 cm
1 MW0.96 m24 cm9.6 cm6.0 cm
2.5 MW1.38 m35 cm14 cm8.6 cm
5 MW1.83 m46 cm18 cm11 cm

Is there a "safe" D*/δx?

Engineering practice often quotes a range of 4–16 (used, among others, in the US NRC validation report NUREG-1824). Keep the NIST caveat in mind, though: in the FDS validation cases D*/δx spans two orders of magnitude and was chosen from grid studies of the specific scenarios, so taking any of these values as a universal minimum is inappropriate. A 10 cm cell may be adequate for smoke spread from a sizeable fire in a building, but not for a small smouldering source.

Cell shape and mesh interfaces

The cost of resolution

Halving the cell size gives about 8 times more cells and a roughly 2 times smaller time step — together about 16 times longer runs (details in how long an FDS simulation takes). A good model therefore has fine cells only where they matter: around the fire source and in the zones you assess (for example escape routes), with coarser meshes elsewhere.

How to run a mesh sensitivity study

  1. Prepare three variants: coarse, baseline and fine (for example 20, 10 and 5 cm in the fire zone).
  2. Choose the quantities your conclusions rest on: temperatures and visibility at devices, smoke layer height, flows through openings, HRR.
  3. Compare the curves. If going from baseline to fine does not change the results in a way that matters for the assessment, the baseline resolution is sufficient.

The variants are independent, so the fastest way is to run them in parallel — in fdsrun each variant starts on its own server, and before the start you see the forecast time and cost of each.

More guides

Sources: FDS User Guide (NIST SP 1019), sections 6.3.1, 6.3.4, 6.3.6; FDS Validation Guide (NIST SP 1018), chapters 3 and 6.1; US NRC NUREG-1824. FDS and Smokeview are software of the National Institute of Standards and Technology; NIST is not affiliated with fdsrun.

Are you sure?